This is a long one. Does it make up for how infrequently I post nowadays? It's been a rough summer, folks.
It also doesn't have a tidy punchline. Except maybe that we should try to be the people we mean to be, even when we're busy doing something else?
A coworker with whom I work often was fired yesterday My feelings on the subject are mixed. I hated working with her: she was always hyper, and always made it seem like the bar was very busy. As a result she was always behind on her chores-- glasses never washed, napkin holders never filled, bar never quite cleaned, fruit bowls never refilled. She could not do anything quickly, and often took a very long time to wait on customers. Throughout, she would always be chattering-- either socializing with customers, which is fine except when the things she is saying to them are about coworkers who are present and in earshot-- she was a consummate master of sarcastic backhanded compliments-- or loudly declaiming and hand-waving about how hard her job was and how she couldn't keep up. She was very defensive about being slow, as well.
But she was a nice woman, intelligent and funny, and our conversations were often very interesting and illuminating. I socialize with her outside of work, and she is always a tremendous amount of fun. She knows how to party, and the hyperactivity that makes her such a chore to work with actually is exceedingly entertaining in any other context.
So, the story:
Rumors have abounded for longer than I've been with the company that this woman would steal money. This is common enough, in any position where cash is handled-- it is relatively easy for any quick-witted cashier or bartender to pocket money if the customer does not wait for their change and receipt, especially if things are either very busy or very quiet.
And it has been known to happen to the best of us-- just Friday night, the Senior Cocktail Waitress and I were out drinking, and she confessed that one day, at the end of her shift, she found a $20 bill in the pocket of her uniform vest. Obviously a customer had given it to her while she was out on the floor, to pay his/her tab. But for the life of her, she could not remember what he'd had. She'd probably poured a round of beers, and brought them out, only to have the customer hand her the money right away-- usually, people sit, and wait for the check to be brought, often after several rounds. So she didn't have it rung up yet, and probably promised to bring him his change and receipt, and then went on to do the million other things a busy cocktail waitress will do.
So she pondered this $20 bill for a little while, and finally at the end of her shift when nobody came back to say, "Hey, did I give you a twenty? I never got my change," she shrugged, and stuck it in her tip cup.
I've occasionally found a five or a ten and done the same thing, usually after stuffing it in my apron. People say, "I don't need change," and I say, "thanks!", pocket the money, and take it off my Urgent To-Do list.
Which is why we are not allowed to put money in our pockets, I might mention. And I rarely do.
Anyhow. Everybody said, this woman steals money. There were a few cashiers rumored to be stealing as well. The company put in secret cameras. They caught a cashier or two. They couldn't ever catch this woman, because they had an idea of "how she was doing it" and wouldn't listen to anyone else's ideas of how it was being done. They could see that her sales were lower than other people's, but were convinced that she was doing something which she was perfectly innocent of. (Apparently twenty years ago bartenders would "ring up" purchases by putting money into the drawer, then taking particular coins and setting them aside in that extra coin cup at the edge of the money drawer to remind themselves of how much of the money in the drawer they hadn't actually rung sales up for, and then give "change", and at the end of the shift they'd count the coins (a penny for a dollar, a nickel for a five, a dime for a ten, a quarter for a twenty) and take out the money they'd put in without ringing up drinks for. So all the managers were doing was watching her coin drawer to see for this telltale sign. But nobody does things that way anymore. Interestingly, this does provide us with an explanation for why they recently suddenly made us unable to open our drawers without ringing up a sale.)
What happens a lot is, people come up to the bar, from the tables, and say, Oh I just want a beer. (Technically, customers at tables are supposed to be waited on by the cocktail waitresses. Big flashing arrow toward me: I am a cocktail waitress. When people get their drinks at the bar to "save me the trouble" that means I am not earning any money and they are taking up my tables preventing people who would buy from (and tip!) ME from sitting down. So I resent this. Professionally. But. It happens. It just happened worse with this particular woman, who was known to call out to customers sitting at tables waiting for me to come take their order that she could get them a drink. So. Yes. Another annoyance.)
She pours them the beer, tells them the price. They give her a round dollar amount just above the price, take the beer, and leave, intending to leave her the change-- usually around twenty to seventy cents depending on the beer.
They never get their change or receipt, and never ask for it. Most bartenders periodically have to make a sweep of the bar to pick up all the receipts and quarters. Funny enough, this particular woman almost never did.
She was usually too busy-- as I've mentioned above, she was always running around even if there weren't many people in the bar. There was always something she had to do, someone she had to talk to, some crisis she had to wave her hands over.
She'd leave the six dollars or whatever lying there on the bar, and after a while she'd pick up all the money the table customers had left on the bar, and she'd go over to her register and ring them in, and just throw out the receipts and drop the change into her tip jar. Reasonable enough. We'd all do that, if it got super busy. Back in the day, on Sundays, when I was bartender and they only gave me one server and the managers never came by, me and the other girl would just collect open checks that didn't need change and throw them into the neat check folders meant to be used for check presentation, and when it finally died down and we weren't so busy, we'd go through and ring them all out. One night we made a paper chain of all the interconnected receipts we'd printed out, and it was as long as the bar. Things get hectic, you gotta do the most urgent things first, and the most urgent things are taking orders, giving back change to them that needs it, bringing out hot food, and pouring drinks, in that order. Putting money in your tip cup comes down near the bottom of the list just above doing dirty dishes. (Money is important and needs to be taken care of. There should never be money just lying around, in a tidy bar. But you don't snatch up tips while customers are still drinking, either. And you don't play with your register while somebody's waiting for service.)
Anyhow.
So this woman.
Monday night, this older couple come up to the bar. They want two Miller Lite drafts. She pours them. The guy hands her eleven dollars (2 Millers comes to $10.57 including tax), and takes the beers over to his wife, who's sitting at a table in the cocktail waitress's section. The bartender's holding the money in her hand, ten on top and one underneath. She takes another order. Talks briefly to the cocktail waitress (who is the one who related all these details to me). IDs a new customer, takes her drink order, offers her a glass of water. Pours her the glass of wine, pours her a glass of water. The wine bottle is empty. "Oh, I have to write this off," she says, and brings it over to her register, where the adjustment sheet where we record empty bottles is. She writes down the empty bottle. Then looks at the ten and the one in her hand, blinks, shrugs, and throws it into her tip jar.
If you were watching this, where would you see the problem?
You probably wouldn't. Particularly in a bar, where the average attention span is usually under a minute. (Behind the bar, anyway.)
But the manager happened to come in, and the cocktail waitress had gone for a smoke break. The couple was sitting at the table, paging through the menu. "Oh," he said, knowing there was no waitress, "did you need anything at all?"
"No, no," they said, "we were just looking."
"Did you get everything you needed?"
"Oh yes," they said. "Just a couple Millers."
"I'm the manager," the manager explains, "and we're always interested in hearing how things are going. Who waited on you and how was the service?"
"Oh," they said, "the woman there, behind the bar, she sold us the beers. She was very nice, very pleasant."
Now the cashiers' registers all have little signs on them: If there's no receipt your purchase is free! The company's really pushing the use of receipts. "Did she give you your receipt?" the manager asked.
The couple looks at one another. "Well, no," they say.
"She's supposed to give a receipt," the manager says, brow furrowed. "Did she put it on the bar and you just didn't take it?"
The couple shrugs. Right at this moment the manager is suddenly getting a clue. He has told certain employees how he thinks this woman is stealing, and a few of us have corrected him, but he has not listened. However, there is a slim chance he is not quite as stupid as he has led us to believe. And now is the time when he begins to prove it.
"What did you have, again?"
"We had two Millers," the man says. "They're nice and cold."
"Good," the manager says, and goes back to the office. He runs a quick report on the computer. What sales has the bartender rung up in the last hour?
There is no record of any transaction of just two Millers. In fact, there is no record of any transaction that is just two draft beers. Almost no transactions of just one draft beer, either. All the draft beers she's rung up have been in combination with some food, or other purchase.
Strange, passing strange, given how many people in that bar are drinking just a draft beer or two, and don't have receipts in front of them.
A sordid tale. I would defend this woman-- these things happen! We all get confused, flustered, distracted! Except that one day, a couple of Italians sat at the bar right next to my station while I was making drinks for my customers out at the tables. They spoke no English. They made clear their desire for a couple of beers. I referred them to the bartender. The woman, shaking her head at their ignorance (except she speaks Italian! I know she does!), pours them two beers. They hand her a twenty.
She never comes back. They sit there. I am there, pouring drinks. I watch them for a while. They grow irritated, shake their heads, watch the bartender.
She never brings them their change.
Twenty dollars. They had nine dollars coming back to them. I watched the whole thing. I was too sick to say anything about it. It's not like it was so busy she forgot. Not like that. Nobody's that forgetful. I'm not going to forget a twenty from a customer who annoyed me. There's just no way.
Even if she did ring up the two beers and only pocketed the change, that's still criminal, and wrong, and bad. And I have disapproved of her ever since, even though I like her outside of work. I've traveled enough abroad to have been ripped off a couple of times, and it stings when someone is so truly evil as that to take advantage of you when you don't speak the language. It's evil.
And the number of times I've had a bar customer say, "The bartender never brought my change. I have two dollars coming to me. She's not paying any attention to me and I've tried to get her attention. Can you tell her to bring my change back? I need the receipt." Oh hell no. I have done that a total of one time ever in my career, and when the guy signaled to me I immediately said, "Oh geez! Your change!" and gave him his thirty cents or whatever. Don't fuck with that shit. It's wrong, and it's dumb, because half the time, they were going to leave it for you anyway-- but it's not a tip if they don't leave it by choice. Tipping only feels good if it's not automatic.
This woman is a devout Christian and speaks about her love for Jesus all the time, her belief in Karma, her love of righteousness. Not that she won't give another girl a lapdance in a bar, or tell a filthy story: she's a fun person and has a great sense of humor. But she is very religious.
I am going, for the sake of argument, to be Christian myself (of the variety that is actually described in Jesus's ostensible Biblical words, the kind that reserves judgement and turns the other cheek and loves its neighbors), and say that her getting fired is Jesus interceding on her behalf. Surely he is a merciful God. (ed note: I don't actually believe that God micromanages like that, but I'm not discounting the balancing forces of a perhaps-divinely-guided karma.) The job was too much temptation for a woman burdened as she was-- divorced with no pension, alone, caring for her aged father, and so on-- and she was not strong enough to resist the temptation to augment her income. I know she was putting it all toward her retirement-- she spoke often of how much she had to save every month because she was in her late fifties and had insufficient savings.
God has interceded by removing the temptation. What she'll do now, I don't know, but I hope it's something she's good at that doesn't put such temptation in her path.